Author’s Note: I originally wrote this for a job application, and think enough time has passed that I can post it here. This is very much an academic analysis; a more personal entry on my love affair with space sims is forthcoming.
Gaming pundits declare genres “dead” with alarming frequency. They are, inevitably, wrong. The adventure, the western RPG, 4X strategy; these have all been declared relics of the past by various industry watchers the moment their sales started to slump. Such doomsaying is short-sighted, and emerges from a view of game development as a linear progression, rather than a rambling path that frequently branches into dead ends and loops back on itself. Dead genres tend to come back in one form or another. Sometimes, as with the RPG, this is a full-blown resurgence; but more often a genre’s resurrection is tied to the independent games movement, with everything from PC platformers to text adventures seeing regular releases.
As far as I can tell, there is a single exception to this rule of genre longevity, and that is the space flight simulator (or “space sim.”)
The space sim died with the old millennium; the genre that burst into prominence with 1990’s Wing Commander saw its last major release in 2000’s Starlancer. When other genres started re-emerging, the space sim stayed quiet. In the decade since their decline, the genre has seen only a few entries, and most (Freelancer, the X series) have been in the “space trading” sub-genre. With only a single notable commercial release (Darkstar One) in the intervening years, the space combat sim truly does seem like a thing of the past.
Why? There doesn’t seem to be a single obvious answer, but a few factors are clear contributors. None of these would have killed it in and of itself, but combined they paint a grim picture of the genre’s future.
1. The Joystick. No other game genre is as reliant on an external peripheral as flight sims. As game budgets rose, developers were understandably reluctant to limit their audience to the joystick-opening population. This kicked off a vicious cycle in which fewer gamers bought joysticks because fewer games took advantage of them.
2. No Outside Audience. The traditional flight sim managed to stay alive despite its reliance on joysticks, largely because it had a dedicated audience of hobbyists and flight enthusiasts who only played flight sims. The tides of the general gaming market ebbed and flowed, but this core user base remained constant. The space combat sim had no equivalent outside audience.
3. PC Centric. More and more, developers have sought ways of porting their PC games to consoles. Yet simulations of all kinds have traditionally struggled on consoles; the limited number of buttons on the gampad makes a realistic emulation of an aircraft’s (or spacecraft’s!) controls impossible. Even the likes of Mechwarrior was essentially untranslatable; the effort to move the series to consoles resulted in MechAssault, a decent arcade game that was about as far from simulating giant robots as Final Fantasy is from actual swordplay. The result is that the market doesn’t really exist, with the Colony Wars series being the only notable space sims on consoles, and those hardly set the charts afire.
4. No Clear Direction Forward. When Freespace 2 was released in 1999, it was widely declared to be the pinnacle of the genre, and it was an astounding feat. Yet it also seemed to be the peak; there was no clear way to improve on the formula, no new juxtapositions of dog fighting and escort missions that would push the formula’s boundaries. In this sense it’s not surprising that the space-trading sim (of which the popular EVE Online is at least a relative) continued to survive; there was simply more room for expansion and experimentation in that open-galaxy modeling.
These four factors are serious setbacks, but don’t make the space sim’s decline any more comforting. I’ve recently been playing the original Independence War, and was reminded that the game really has no equivalent; no other game genre (and certainly no other medium) can offer the peculiar, alien experience of claustrophobia and infinite space that the space sim can. And while it’s certainly dormant for now, history has shown that it’s folly to declare anything in gaming truly dead. The question, then, is what will resuscitate the glories of the capitol ship battle. Any ideas?